November 19, 2026

Trump aims to end birthright citizenship, says American citizens with family here illegally may be deported

Interestingly, nearly every nation that offers birthright citizenship is located in North or South America.

Trump aims to end birthright citizenship, says American citizens with family here illegally may be deported

President-elect Donald Trump, in an exclusive interview with “Meet the Press,” also said he is open to working with Democrats on a legislative way to keep Dreamers in the United States.

President-elect Donald Trump said in an interview with “Meet the Press” moderator Kristen Welker that “you have no choice” but to deport everyone who is illegally in the U.S., including possibly removing the American citizen family members of those deported.

Trump also said he will move to end birthright citizenship — long enshrined in the 14th Amendment of the Constitution — which would strip rights from those born in the country to undocumented parents.

But, he said, he is open to working with Democrats to pass legislation that would ensure Dreamers — undocumented immigrants who entered the U.S. as children — would be able to remain in the country.

Trump’s comments about his mass deportation plan, a key promise of his presidential campaign, were the most expansive since he won the election in November. The program, he said, will begin with undocumented immigrants who have committed crimes and then advance to “people outside of criminals.” He did not detail which crimes would be included.

“I think you have to do it,” Trump said of his deportation effort. “It’s a very tough thing to do. It’s — but you have to have, you know, you have rules, regulations, laws. They came in illegally. You know, the people that have been treated very unfairly are the people that have been on line for 10 years to come into the country.”

“We have to get the criminals out of our country,” Trump said, later adding: “But we’re starting with the criminals, and we got to do it. And then we’re starting with others, and we’re going to see how it goes.”

Asked by Welker, “Who are the others?” Trump responded, “Others are other people outside of criminals.”

There was a large increase in the number of unauthorized immigrants crossing into the U.S. during President Joe Biden’s time in office, though that number has fallen following executive actions in recent months.

Tightening restrictions around the U.S. border with Mexico was at the forefront of Trump’s candidacy — much as it was during his first run in 2016. Trump and allies routinely highlighted acts of violence committed by undocumented immigrants to bolster their case. (A 2024 study from the National Institute of Justice found that Texas arrest records between 2012 and 2018 showed undocumented immigrants were arrested at less than half the rate of native-born Americans for violent crimes.)

Trump also described scenarios in which U.S. citizens may choose to be deported along with family members in the country illegally. His comments echoed Tom Homan, his pick to serve as border czar in the upcoming administration, in saying that he will be deporting families with mixed immigration status together.

“Let me ask you about another group of people, the estimated 4 million families in America who have mixed immigration status. So I’m talking about parents who might be here illegally,” Welker said, “but the kids are here

“I don’t want to be breaking up families,” Trump said. “So the only way you don’t break up the family is you keep them together and you have to send them all back.”

Welker also asked about the zero-tolerance policy during Trump’s first term, where families would be separated at the border as a means of deterrence for those who chose to enter the U.S. illegally. Trump eventually ended the practice.

“We don’t have to separate families,” Trump said. “We’ll send the whole family very humanely, back to the country where they came.”

“So no more family separations?” Welker asked. “You’re not reviving the zero-tolerance policy?”

“It depends on the family,” Trump said, adding later: “If they come here illegally but their family is here legally, then the family has a choice. The person that came in illegally can go out, or they can all go out together.”

On birthright citizenship, Trump said he would seek to repeal it via executive action — which would be certain to spark immediate legal challenges.

“We have to end it,” Trump said, calling it “ridiculous.”

Trump suggested that birthright citizenship is uniquely American, saying, “We’re the only country that has it, you know.” But according to a review by the Library of Congress, more than 30 nations provide birthright citizenship, including Canada and Brazil.

More at:


Countries with Birthright Citizenship 2024

Countries with Birthright Citizenship 2024

Birthright citizenship is a governmental policy under which any child born within a country’s borders or territory is automatically granted citizenship in that country-even if their parents are not citizens. At present, 33 countries in the world (and two territories) have unrestricted birthright citizenship, also known as jus soli, and another 32 nations have some form of restricted birthright citizenship (see table after body text).

Birthright citizenship is a governmental policy under which any child born within a country’s borders or territory is automatically granted citizenship in that country—even if their parents are not citizens. At present, 33 countries in the world (and two territories) have unrestricted birthright citizenship, also known as jus soli, and another 32 nations have some form of restricted birthright citizenship (see table after body text).

Every Country with Unrestricted Birthright Citizenship (jus soli):

The following countries have unrestricted birthright citizenship: Antigua and Barbuda, Argentina, Barbados, Belize, Bolivia, Brazil, Canada, Chad, Child, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Ecuador, El Salvador, Fiji, Grenada, Guatemala, Guyana, Honduras, Jamaica, Lesotho, Mexico, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Tanzania, Trinidad and Tobago, Tuvalu, the United States, Uruguay, and Venezuela.

Nuances of birthright citizenship

Interestingly, nearly every nation that offers birthright citizenship is located in North or South America. This is considered by many scholars to have begun in colonial times, in which European countries eager to populate their settlements in the “New World” established more lenient and immigration-friendly citizenship policies. It should also be noted that birthright citizenship often has at least one exception: The children of foreign ambassadors or other diplomats serving in a country for work are frequently excluded.

In addition to the nations listed above, various other countries may offer birthright citizenship under certain circumstances. For instance, Luxembourg, Guinea-Bissau, Azerbaijan, and Chad will sometimes grant jus soli when the child is orphaned. Chad extends jus soli, but not until the child reaches the age of 18, when they can choose whether to accept Chadian citizenship or that of their parents. Tanzania has a similar system in which a newborn child is granted jus soli until the age of 18, at which time they must choose one citizenship or the other.

Benefits of living in a country that offers birthright citizenship

One of the most significant benefits to living in a country that upholds birthright citizenship is that it grants citizenship to anyone born in that country with no other requirements. This can give the child valuable legal rights, such as protecting them from unwarranted extradition or enabling them to benefit from social programs that would not otherwise be available to them.

Benefits such as this are the reason expectant parents are sometimes compelled to move to a country that offers birthright citizenship. Depending upon their current situation, they can sometimes secure a better life for their children simply by giving birth in a different country—provided it has birthright citizenship.

Birthright citizenship also has opponents. These are typically citizens of the “host” nation who feel the policy enables foreigners to enter the country for the sole purpose of giving birth to “anchor babies”, a practice which exploits the system and siphons off funds that would otherwise be used to benefit existing citizens. Such “birth tourism” is illegal in the United States, though the procedures used to deter or detect the perpetrators and enforce the laws are not always clear.

The difference between jus soli and jus sanguinis

In contrast to jus soli, nearly every other country on Earth offers jus sanguinis, which grants citizenship as long as one parent (or sometimes both parents) are citizens. Examples of this include Poland (both parents), Andorra (mother), Bahrain (father) and Iran (father). This is sometimes referred to as establishing citizenship through inheritance rather than residence.

How birthright citizenship, jus soli, and jus sanguinis work in various countries

Antigua and Barbuda

There are three ways of receiving citizenship in the Caribbean country of Antigua and Barbuda. Birthright citizenship is one way. Any individual born in Antigua and Barbuda on or before October 31, 1981 (the date the policy went into effect) is considered a citizen by birth.

The other two ways of acquiring citizenship are descent (having a parent or grandparent who is a citizen) and naturalization (live three years with a spouse who is a citizen or live unmarried in the country for seven years). These two variations of obtaining citizenship are still valid. Still, they involve playing an active part in getting your citizenship rather than receiving it at the time of your birth.

Pakistan

In 1951, the Pakistan Citizenship Act established an all-encompassing birthright citizenship policy, declaring that anyone born in Pakistan is naturally and officially considered a citizen of the country of Pakistan—even if they were born before the Act had entered into force. The Pakistan Citizenship Act also defines two other ways of obtaining citizenship: descent or legal migration. These three ways of acquiring citizenship in Pakistan are very similar, if not identical, to other countries’ citizenship processes around the world.

United States

The United States of America declared birthright citizenship for USA-born individuals in 1868, as part of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, which was created in the wake of the Civil War. In addition to granting citizenship to all former slaves in the United States, the 14th Amendment officially established that any child born on U.S. soil (meaning any U.S. state or territory) was automatically a citizen of the United States.

75 countries

IndiaRestrictedIf one parent is citizen and the other a citizen or legal migrant (as of 2020).
PakistanRestrictedChildren of refugees are ineligible.
JapanRestrictedIf born to “stateless” or unknown parents.
EgyptRestrictedIf one parent was also born in Egypt.
IranRestrictedIf one parent was born in Iran.
GermanyRestrictedIf at least one parent has a permanent residence permit and has lived in Germany at least 8 years.
ThailandRestrictedIf parents are legal residents for at least five years.
United KingdomRestrictedIf one parent is citizen or legally settled in the country or if child has lived in country for 10 y…
FranceRestrictedIf one parent is French citizen or born in France. Or upon 18th birthday if you’ve lived in France a…
South AfricaRestrictedIf parents are citizens or permanent residents.
ItalyRestrictedIf one of parent’s descendant was a citizen, or if child has lived in country untill 18th birthday, …
ColombiaRestrictedIf one parent is citizen or legal resident.
SudanRestrictedIf father was born in Sudan.
SpainRestrictedIf one parent was born in Spain or if parents are stateless.
MoroccoRestrictedIf parents were born in Morocco, child can register for citizenship.
UkraineRestrictedIf parents have refugee status in Ukraine, or if child is stateless.
MalaysiaRestrictedIf one parent is a citizen or permanent resident.
AustraliaRestrictedIf one parent is citizen or permanent resident or if child has lived in country for 10 years.
TaiwanRestrictedIf parents are Taiwanese citizens or if parents are stateless or unknown.
NetherlandsRestrictedIf one parent is a citizen and lives in the country at the time of the child’s birth, or if a grandp…
CambodiaRestrictedIf parents are living legally in Cambodia.
TunisiaRestrictedIf father and grandfather were born in Tunisia. Child must claim citizenship before age 20.
BelgiumRestrictedIf one parent was born in Belgium and has lived there for 10 years, or 5 years before child’s birth.
Dominican RepublicRestrictedMildly restricted.
SwedenRestrictedIf one parent is citizen (for children born before April 1, 2015).
PortugalRestrictedIf child is born with no other nationality, or child petitions for citizenship and one parent lived …
GreeceRestrictedIf parents live in Greece 5-10 years and child attends preschool, or if child has unknown or no othe…
IsraelRestrictedChildren born in Israel who have no other citizenship can apply for Israeli citizenship between ages…
Hong KongRestrictedComplicated compatibilities with mainland China.
FinlandRestrictedIf mother is citizen and born in country or if father is a citizen and married to mother.
IrelandRestrictedIf one parent is citizen of Ireland or Britain or is legal resident three of last four years.
New ZealandRestrictedIf one parent is citizen or permanent resident or if child is stateless.
MongoliaRestrictedIf parents are valid residents or unidentified. Child must accept citizenship at age 16.
NamibiaRestrictedIf one parent was also born in or regularly lives in Namibia.
BahrainRestrictedIf father was born in Bahrain.
CyprusRestrictedIf one parent is citizen or born in country.
MacauRestrictedComplicated compatibilities with mainland China.
LuxembourgRestrictedIf at least one parent was born in country, or if child has lived in country 5 straight years after …
MaltaRestrictedIf one parent is citizen or born in country.
Sao Tome and PrincipeRestrictedIf parents are residents.
United StatesUnrestricted
BrazilUnrestricted
MexicoUnrestricted
TanzaniaUnrestricted
ArgentinaUnrestricted
CanadaUnrestricted
PeruUnrestricted
VenezuelaUnrestricted
ChadUnrestrictedUnrestricted, but child chooses to opt in or out at age 18.
ChileUnrestrictedChild can choose to opt in or out.
GuatemalaUnrestricted
EcuadorUnrestricted
BoliviaUnrestricted
CubaUnrestricted
HondurasUnrestricted
ParaguayUnrestricted
NicaraguaUnrestricted
El SalvadorUnrestricted
Costa RicaUnrestricted
PanamaUnrestricted
UruguayUnrestricted
JamaicaUnrestricted
LesothoUnrestricted
Trinidad and TobagoUnrestricted
FijiUnrestricted
GuyanaUnrestricted
BelizeUnrestricted
BarbadosUnrestricted
Saint LuciaUnrestricted
GrenadaUnrestricted
Saint Vincent and the GrenadinesUnrestricted
Antigua and BarbudaUnrestricted
DominicaUnrestricted
Saint Kitts and NevisUnrestricted
TuvaluUnrestricted

Which countries have birthright citizenship?

The following countries have unrestricted birthright citizenship: Antigua and Barbuda, Argentina, Barbados, Belize, Bolivia, Brazil, Canada, Chad, Chile, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Ecuador, El Salvador, Fiji, Grenada, Guatemala, Guyana, Honduras, Jamaica, Lesotho, Mexico, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Tanzania, Trinidad and Tobago, Tuvalu, the United States, Uruguay, and Venezuela.


Birthright Citizenship: The 14th Amendment Does Not Apply to Illegal Aliens

Birthright Citizenship: The 14th Amendment Does Not Apply to Illegal Aliens

America is about to go to war over whether the government has the power to deport entire families of illegal aliens. That question involves “birthright citizenship”-that is, whether a child born in the U.S. to illegal alien parents …

America is about to go to war over whether the government has the power to deport entire families of illegal aliens. That question involves “birthright citizenship”—that is, whether a child born in the U.S. to illegal alien parents is automatically a U.S. citizen and, thus, an “anchor baby?”

The answer, by any fair reading of the Constitution and history, is “No.”

Our nation must have complete control of our borders. No illegal alien should be able to circumvent the laws of our nation. English common law, the basis for U.S. law, did not allow such people, the children of “hostile occupiers,” to become citizens by virtue of birth. Moreover, the 14th Amendment, which was passed to cure the ill of slavery, establishes a two-part test for citizenship that seemingly codifies English common law and is clearly meant to apply to those who came here against their will and their descendants, not to criminal invaders.

The anchor baby problem is significant. Donald Trump recently said that the Biden administration has “abolished what remained of America’s borders and turned the United States into a dumping ground for illegal aliens from all over the world.” A lowball guess is that Biden’s lawless conduct allowed in at eight least million illegal aliens, although the number could easily be twice that. This influx is causing havoc throughout the U.S.—and even gave rise to a bit of dark musical humor from The Kiffness:

Democrats, however, will immediately challenge that plan in the federal court (aided by the fact that Americans are squeamish about separating families). The argument will be based on the legal theory that you can’t deport families when they include an American citizen. The question revolves around “birthright citizenship”: Does a child born of alien parents, especially those here illegally, automatically becomes an American citizen if that child is born inside America’s borders?

A history of birthright citizenship

English Common Law

Because the U.S. was formed on the Anglo legal tradition, the Supreme Court regularly holds that British law before 1776 is the basis of and starting point for American law. That means turning to pre-1776 English citizenship law.

In 1608, the English Exchequer decided Calvin’s Case, which asked whether a Scotsman had the legal right to own land in England. The case’s facts are irrelevant today, but the legal holding is not. As later summarized by Lord Chief Justice Cockburn, two factors can block a child born on English soil from being an English citizen—the children of ambassadors and the children of foreign invaders during a hostile takeover of British territory:

‘By the common law of England, every person born within the dominions of the crown, no matter whether of English or of foreign parents, and, in the latter case, whether the parents were settled, or merely temporarily sojourning, in the country, was an English subject, save only the children of foreign ambassadors (who were excepted because their fathers carried their own nationality with them), or a child born to a foreigner during the hostile occupation of any part of the territories of England. (Emphasis added.)

The emphasized clause aptly describes the children of illegal aliens who unlawfully invade U.S. lands.

Slavery and Citizenship

Slavery muddled the clarity of U.S. citizenship law, coming to a head in 1857 with the Supreme Court’s Dred Scott decision.

Scott was a slave who had sued for his freedom in lower courts. By the time the case reached the Supreme Court, the sole question was, “Can a negro, whose ancestors were imported into this country, and sold as slaves, become a…citizen?”

The Court ruled that Africans and their descendants could not become citizens under federal law because of the interplay between state and federal law and because the federal government lacked the power to outlaw slavery in both the states and the territories. As Prof. Sean Wilentz deftly dissects in his exceptional book, No Property in Man, both holdings boldly misread the Founders’ original intention when drafting the Constitution.

Not long after the Dred Scott decision, the Civil War began. In 1865, when the Confederacy was vanquished, Congress ratified the “Reconstruction Amendments.” The 13th Amendment abolished slavery, the 14th Amendment gave former slaves and freemen equal legal rights, and the 15th Amendment gave former slaves and black freemen the right to vote.

To cure the citizenship question that the Dred Scott case created for former slaves and black freemen, the 14th Amendment created a two-part citizenship test:

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. (Emphasis added.)

Unfortunately, little of the debate and legislative history regarding the drafting of this clause was recorded. Additionally, while this formulation seems to restate the law of Calvin’s Case, it is not definitive. What is clear is that mere birth inside of our borders is insufficient to impart citizenship.

Birthright Citizenship and the 14th Amendment

In 1898, the Supreme Court addressed the 14th Amendment’s citizenship clause in United States v. Wong Kim Ark. Wong Kim Ark’s parents were Chinese citizens doing business in America. The government gave them permission to reside lawfully and permanently in the U.S.

Because Wong Kim Ark’s parents were legally domiciled in America, the Supreme Court held that their child was entitled to American citizenship when he was born. That holding is consistent with Calvin’s Case and does not create a precedent for citizenship by illegal aliens exercising a veto over American laws.

The only other case of note happened 90 years later. In 1985’s INS v. Rios-Pineda, Supreme Court Justice Byron White wrote in his recitation of facts that “Deportation proceedings were then instituted against respondents, who by that time had a child, who, being born in the United States, was a United States citizen.” That bare assertion can be safely ignored. This was mere dicta and did not establish new constitutional law. The child’s citizenship was not at issue in the case, and was not argued before the Court.

Summary

The 14th Amendment must be interpreted in light of its time and place. It’s ludicrous to believe that the same Congress that adopted the 14th Amendment to benefit former slaves—people forcibly brought to America and their descendants—meant to change fundamentally the ancient English principle that children born to hostile invaders on English soil (or, in our case, American soil) cannot become citizens.

This interpretation would also run directly counter to the maxim that “it is the inherent right of every independent nation to determine for itself, and according to its own constitution and laws, what classes of persons shall be entitled to its citizenship.” When progressives’ screams about birthright citizenship for illegal aliens’ children reach a fever pitch in the coming weeks and months, know that they are lying to you.

More at:


Share the News